Announcing the Prosblogion Virtual Colloquium
October 2, 2016 — 15:29

Author: Kenny Pearce  Category: Housekeeping  Tags: , , , ,   Comments: 4

In the coming weeks, I will begin running a new feature on this blog which I am calling ‘the Prosblogion Virtual Colloquium’. Like a real philosophy department colloquium, the virtual colloquium aims to be a weekly discussion of a philosophy paper. This being the Prosblogion, these will of course be papers in philosophy of religion. However, this term will be construed in a very broad sense to include philosophy papers in any field and any tradition that are relevant to religion in general or to any particular religion. I will be trying, as much as possible, to span the full diversity of philosophers, philosophical projects, arguments and positions that fall within that very general characterization of philosophy of religion. The colloquium will primarily feature the work of junior scholars.

I have several aims for this project. First, I hope simply that this will foster interesting discussion of philosophical issues related to religion(s). Second, I think it is an unfortunate feature of the academic discipline of philosophy that many excellent papers are barely read and commented on at all. I therefore hope that the virtual colloquium will help a variety of philosophy papers to be part of a genuine conversation (and maybe not wait years to be cited for the first time!). Third, I hope that the series will help to bring attention to the diverse kinds of work being undertaken in contemporary philosophy of religion and the variety of positions and arguments being defended. Finally, I hope that this will provide an opportunity for philosophers who don’t get to attend conferences and colloquia on a regular basis to engage in helpful back-and-forth philosophical discussion at a high level.

I am open to suggestions about format, but my current plan is as follows. Just like an in-person colloquium, I will briefly introduce the colloquium ‘speaker’. Following this, the ‘speaker’ will give an introductory summary of the paper under discussion (recommended length about 800 words, but flexible). Then there will be a link to the full text of the paper. The paper may be a draft or a recent publication, but must be online somewhere. Open access is of course preferable, but where this is infeasible for copyright reasons a link to the journal (or PhilPapers) to allow those who have access through their university would be acceptable.

If there is sufficient interest, I hope to run the first virtual colloquium on Friday, October 14 and hold subsequent colloquia each Friday through at least the end of the present academic year. I am beginning to contact potential presenters right away. I would appreciate receiving nominations particularly of junior philosophers who have a draft or recent publication in philosophy of religion to discuss. These can be left in the comments below, or sent by email to Receiving plenty of nominations from lots of different people will help to ensure the schedule does not end up unduly biased toward my own philosophical propensities. Self-nominations are also encouraged!

Religious disagreement survey
November 20, 2014 — 8:01

Author: Helen De Cruz  Category: Concept of God Religious Belief  Tags: , ,   Comments: 0

What do philosophers think about religious disagreement? This is a brief survey (takes about 5-10 minutes) to find this out. The survey is aimed at academic philosophers, by which I mean people who hold a PhD in philosophy or are graduate students in philosophy. If you fit these criteria, please consider participating. Participation is fully anonymous.

The format of the study is a multiple choice questionnaire. I will ask some personal questions, amongst others about your religious views, but your name will not be asked. To further take care that your anonymity is preserved, I will not report on individual responses but report statistical patterns. There are a few places where you can provide an open response (optional). I will publish at most one open response per participant, making sure that there is no identifying information within your response. The full dataset will remain confidential and will not be shared with anyone. I will report the preliminary results on Prosblogion and two other websites.

The study is designed and carried out by Helen De Cruz, postdoctoral fellow of the British Academy at the University of Oxford. If you have any questions or concerns, please contact helen.decruz- at – To participate, please click here or paste this link in your browser:

Position at the University of Texas at San Antonio
August 27, 2013 — 14:10

Author: Michael Almeida  Category: News  Tags:   Comments: 0

[Full description of the position can be found here](
Please don’t hesitate to ask me about the position either here at Prosblogion or at Thanks!

God’s Existence and My Suspicion: Delusions of Knowledge
July 12, 2013 — 10:02

Author: Keith DeRose  Category: Atheism & Agnosticism Existence of God Religious Belief  Tags: , , ,   Comments: 72

(I thought some Prosblogion folks may find this essay interesting, because it touches on and connects with several interesting philosophical and metaphilosophical issues, and also some interesting issues about the role of faith in the religious life. I don’t mention faith in the essay: that’s one of the “connected” issues that isn’t actually touched on. But it’s interesting to me to see how some theists can be very disturbed at the suggestion that they don’t know that God exists, while others shrug it off with some thought along the lines of “Well, that’s what faith is for.”)

I know many people who claim to know whether God exists. In each case (individually), I suspect they’re wrong about their having such knowledge. In fact, I suspect that they are all wrong. That is, I suspect that nobody that I know knows whether God exists. So I suspect that delusions of knowledge about this matter run rampant among folks I know. Not a particularly nice suspicion to harbor, I realize. But I thought I’d express and explain that suspicion here, describing my grounds for it.


Survey Request
June 23, 2013 — 20:32

Author: Matthew Mullins  Category: Uncategorized  Tags: , ,   Comments: 1

Reader Kevin Tobia writes with the following request:

I am currently a graduate student in philosophy working on a project in the philosophy of religion. My project involves a brief survey and I would be incredibly grateful if interested Prosblogion readers would help me by taking it. You do not need to be a faculty member, or even a philosopher to take the survey. It should take about 5 minutes and if you have any questions, please feel free to contact me at The survey link is here:
Thank you for your help!

Nagel on Plantinga’s New Book
September 15, 2012 — 13:20

Author: Andrew Moon  Category: Atheism & Agnosticism Books of Interest Existence of God Religious Belief  Tags: , , , ,   Comments: 4

Thomas Nagel writes a review of Alvin Plantinga’s recent book, Where the Conflict Really Lies, which James Beebe has also nicely reviewed here at Prosblogion.
Nagel’s review is well-written and charitable. He covers much territory by summarizing large swathes of Plantinga-philosophy in succinct paragraphs, all without sacrificing accuracy. (He even appears to have carefully read footnotes from Plantinga’s other works.) His only objection seemed to be that Plantinga does not consider naturalist theories of mental content. Plantinga doesn’t cover them in this book, but he deals with a number of them in a recent PPR paper.
So, as one very familiar with Plantinga’s work, I was impressed with Nagel’s review.

Plantinga Recovering Well from Heart Surgery
June 3, 2012 — 8:02

Author: Trent Dougherty  Category: News  Tags: ,   Comments: 4

From all of us here at Prosblogion and the readership I’m sure: Get well soon!
First, Al did NOT have a heart attack. If you hear that, it’s not true (and it’s false if you didn’t hear it). On Friday, Al had triple bypass surgery to remove some blockage. By all accounts he is recovering well.
When I was with Al for an extended time a little more than a month ago, he was quite vigorous and in great shape, so I can’t imagine what super-powers he’ll have when his recovery is complete and he has achieved maximal health.
Atheists and agnostics, it wouldn’t *hurt* if you sent up a few tentative or conditional prayers to join the rest of us! 😉

Younger Scholars Prizes–$8000
May 17, 2012 — 7:31

Author: Jon Kvanvig  Category: News  Tags: ,   Comments: 0

Since the summer break is nearly here, I thought I’d remind folks of the Younger Scholars Prize so that the summer break could be used to write/finish entries. Here’s the ad:
Prosblogion readers will most likely be interested in the competition details for the Younger Scholars Prize for Philosophical Theology.

NDPR review of “Evidence and Religious Belief”
February 18, 2012 — 11:32

Author: Andrew Moon  Category: Books of Interest Links Religious Belief  Tags:   Comments: Off

See here. The article’s by our very own Prosblogion contributor Trent Dougherty!

Survey on natural theological arguments
February 7, 2012 — 10:04

Author: Helen De Cruz  Category: Existence of God  Tags: , , , ,   Comments: 9

I’d like to thank Matthew Mullins for inviting me to post at Prosblogion. My first entry is going to be a request for help. I would be very grateful if Prosblogion readers could fill out the following, very brief survey:

It will take only about three minutes of your time. The survey is part of my current project on cognitive science and natural theology. The aim is to get a better idea of how philosophers today evaluate natural theological arguments for or against the existence of God. Note that you do not need to be a philosopher of religion or a faculty member to complete this survey. I will post a digest of the results in a few weeks. The survey will be active until I have gathered a predetermined number of responses that would allow for statistically robust results or until two weeks have elapsed.