This is the last installment of the Prosblogion Reading Group. I've found reading these posts and comments edifying, and I hope the rest of the readers have as well. I'd like to thank Matthew for setting this up, and for the other participants--both posters and commenters--for their great thoughts.
Below I discuss Tooley's response to Plantinga's response to Tooley. Or, put another way, Tooley's "Yes way!" to Plantinga's "No way!" To keep my comments at a manageable length I've referred back to Trent and Andrew's posts, rather than presenting the whole dialectic here. But I've tried to summarize the dialectic briefly in most places. For more detail on the original argument or Plantinga's response, be sure to see the discussions of the last two weeks.
Continue reading Reading Group Week 8: Tooley's Closing Statement and Response to Plantinga's Comments.
